Ernest Hemingway and his Literary Critics

December 08, 2022

Ernest Hemingway and his Literary Critics

Between 1925 and 1961, Hemingway wrote and published seven novels, six short story collections, and two works of non-fiction. He was a leading figure of the so-called Lost Generation and forever changed American fiction. We are lucky enough to have a handful of Hemingway first editions, including a signed printing of A Farewell to Arms and Men Without Women, in our current inventory.   

Hemingway’s rise from promising unknown writer to world-renowned figure can be charted by the very newspapers and magazines in which his work so regularly appeared. While it is not always common for an author to be celebrated for his writing in his own time, this was not the case for Hemingway. Reading through the slate of book reviews from that time, one can glean both the fascination with the author himself and the critical appreciation for his short, unadorned phrases and way with words. In fact, the positive critical reviews did much to fuel the cult of personality surrounding this epic writer. 

Read the excerpts, below, to track Hemingway's rise to literary fame. 

Men Without Women, Signed and Inscribed by Ernest Hemingway, Uniform Edition, 1955

Men Without Women

“It is a warm gratification to find the new Hemingway book, “Men Without Women,” a truly magnificent work. It is composed of thirteen short stories, most of which have been published before. They are sad and terrible stories; the author’s enormous appetite for life seems to have been somehow appeased. You find here little of that peaceful ecstasy that marked the camping trip in “The Sun Also Rises” and the lone fisherman’s days in “Big Two-Hearted River,” in “In Our Time.” The stories include “The Killers,” which seems to me one of the four great American short stories… The book also includes “Fifty Grand,” “In Another Country,” and the delicate and tragic “Hills Like White Elephants.” I do not know where a greater collection of stories can be found.”- Dorothy Parker, The New Yorker, October 22, 1927 

A Farewell to Arms, Signed by Ernest Hemingway, First Edition, Later Printing, in Later Dust Jacket, 1929

A Farewell to Arms

"There is in A Farewell to Arms no change from the narrative method of The Sun Also Rises and Men Without Women. Ernest Hemingway did not invent the method, which is chiefly to be characterized by the staccato nature of sentences (an effort at reproducing universal conversational habit), and its rigid exclusion of all but the most necessary description. Yet if Hemingway was not the inventor of the method, tentative gropings toward such a manner having been made by many of his immediate predecessors, the author of A Farewell to Arms has, in his several books, made it so strikingly his own that it may bear his name, and is likely to henceforward." – Percy Hutchison, The New York Times, September 29, 1929

To Have And Have Not by Ernest Hemingway, First Edition, 1937

To Have and Have Not 

"The strange case of Ernest Hemingway is reopened this morning with the publication of "To Have and Have Not," his first novel since "A Farewell to Arms." It is a turbulent, searching story of Key West and Havana in these strange years of grace. There is as much violent action as you will find in a historical novel--and far, far better writing. The characters kill one another as freely as though they were directed by statesmen of civilized nations. It seems probable that this new book--stronger than "The Sun Also Rises," not as good as "A Farewell to Arms"--will do more to renew the uproar than to close the case. The open season for rousing Whither Hemingway? essays is decidedly here again." - Charles Poore, The New York Times, October 15, 1937 

For Whom The Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway, First Blakiston Edition, 1940

For Whom the Bell Tolls

"It is fourteen years since The Sun Also Rises and eleven since A Farewell to Arms. More than three hundred years ago John Donne said, ‘No man is an Iland, intire of it selfe; every man is a peece of the Continent, a part of the maine. And therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.’ Mr. Hemingway has taken this text and, out of his experiences, convictions and great gifts, built on it his finest novel." – Ralph Thompson, The New York Times, October 21, 1940

The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway, First Edition, 1952

The Old Man and the Sea

"Within the sharp restrictions imposed by the very nature of his story Mr. Hemingway has written with sure skill. Here is the master technician once more at the top of his form, doing superbly what he can do better than anyone else." –Orville Prescott, The New York Times, August 28, 1952

Click here to see all available Ernest Hemingway titles at The Great Republic. 

Also in Blog

From Corsica to Saint Helena- the Eccentric Life of Napoleon Bonaparte
From Corsica to Saint Helena- the Eccentric Life of Napoleon Bonaparte

May 31, 2023

A famed military figure, Napoleon Bonaparte is arguably one of the most famous Frenchmen to ever emerge out of the 19th century. His legacy endures in the form of endless literature that meticulously analyzes his entire life from start to finish, particularly his military campaigns during the Napoleonic Wars

View full article →

Illustrating Mark Twain's "Huckleberry Finn"
Illustrating Mark Twain's "Huckleberry Finn"

May 17, 2023

The drawings Edward Kemble produced for Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were his first book illustrations, and the ones he is still best known for. A young yet prodigious illustrator for magazines and newspapers like Harper's Bazaar and New York Graphic, Kemble’s cartoon work in Life caught the attention of Mark Twain. Mark Twain personally requested Kemble for Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, telling his publisher “That is the man I want to try.” There are approximately 175 illustrations in Huck Finn, for which Kemble was paid the large sum of $2,000.00. Read more about his artistic process and collaboration with Mark Twain. 

View full article →

Designing the Stars and Stripes
Designing the Stars and Stripes

May 08, 2023

Most historians credit Francis Hopkinson as the designer of the first American flag. Read more about the story behind the star pattern.

View full article →